Garage forums are full of people quoting monthly heating bills from $20 to $400, and both ends are right. The spread comes down to two things: whether the garage is insulated, and whether you keep it warm all week or heat it only while you're out there. Here's what each combination costs, using the same model as our garage heater calculator.
All figures are for an attached 2-car garage (24 × 24 ft, 9-ft ceiling) when it averages 30°F outside, at $1.70 per therm for natural gas, $2.50 a gallon for propane and 18¢ per kWh for electricity. "Heat pump" means a ductless mini-split.
Uninsulated 2-Car Garage: Monthly Cost
| How you heat it | Natural gas | Propane | Electric | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keep at 40°F all the time | $98 | $157 | $243 | $97 |
| Keep at 50°F all the time | $196 | $315 | $486 | $195 |
| 60°F, 8 hours a week | $17 | $28 | $43 | $17 |
| 60°F, 20 hours a week | $44 | $70 | $108 | $43 |
An open-stud garage with a bare ceiling and an uninsulated door loses about 630 BTU an hour for every degree it's warmer than outside. Holding 50°F all winter turns that into a bill most people won't accept: about $315 a month with propane. Heating it to 60°F only during an 8-hour weekend project costs a tenth of that.
Fully Insulated 2-Car Garage: Monthly Cost
| How you heat it | Natural gas | Propane | Electric | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keep at 40°F all the time | $32 | $52 | $81 | $32 |
| Keep at 50°F all the time | $65 | $104 | $161 | $64 |
| 60°F, 8 hours a week | $6 | $9 | $14 | $6 |
| 60°F, 20 hours a week | $14 | $23 | $36 | $14 |
Insulating the walls, ceiling and door cuts heat loss by about two-thirds. That's what makes keep-warm heating affordable: about $65 a month on natural gas or a mini-split to hold 50°F. If you only heat it a few hours a week, insulation saves $10–$30 a month and takes years to pay back, so it's worth doing mainly if you plan to keep the space warm.
What Size Heater a Garage Needs
Heater output needed to hold 60°F when it's 0°F outside, for attached garages with 9-ft ceilings:
| Garage | No insulation | Walls only | Fully insulated |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1-car | 22,000 BTU/hr | 17,000 BTU/hr | 8,000 BTU/hr |
| 2-car | 38,000 BTU/hr | 32,000 BTU/hr | 13,000 BTU/hr |
| 3-car | 53,000 BTU/hr | 45,000 BTU/hr | 17,000 BTU/hr |
For reference, a 1,500 W plug-in space heater makes about 5,100 BTU an hour, enough only for a small, insulated space. An uninsulated 2-car garage needs a 40,000–45,000 BTU propane or gas unit heater; an insulated one can get by on a 4–5 kW, 240-volt electric heater. Detached garages lose a little more because none of their walls touch the house.
Which Fuel Is Cheapest for a Garage
At these prices, natural gas and a ductless heat pump tie for the cheapest heat, propane costs about 60% more, and electric resistance heat about 2.5 times as much. But installation decides it for most people: a gas line or propane tank and a vent for a unit heater, a 240-volt circuit for an electric heater, or several thousand dollars for a mini-split, which also air-conditions the space in summer. For occasional use, the cheapest heater to install is often the right one, since the monthly bill is small either way.
Avoid running unvented propane or kerosene heaters for long periods. They dump combustion moisture and exhaust into the garage, which rusts tools and can raise carbon monoxide levels.